CRE Meets Impact Investing, Our Field’s Spookiest Tricks & Treats, & Hello Cal Wellness

Welcome to the latest installment of Intention 2 Impact’s Heart-2-Heart — our monthly newsletter where we share what’s on our mind, in our hearts, and up our sleeves.

This month, we’re making the case that evaluators belong in the impact-investing room (even when the room is empty 👀), naming the scariest things in our field (and the treats that keep us going), and welcoming the California Wellness Foundation as one of I2I’s newest clients.

ON OUR MINDS

The Roundtable Nobody Came To 🪑

Three women smiling together at the CREA IX conference, wearing their conference badges

Picture it: a round table at a Chicago conference. A stack of freshly printed handouts. A ring of empty chairs. And one very well-prepared Nina.

Earlier this month, I2I’s Nina Sabarre attended CREA IX, the Ninth International Conference of the Center for Culturally Responsive Evaluation and Assessment, for the first time. Spoiler: we’re converts. CREA is cozy, around 350 people, and everyone there shares more than a job title. They share a commitment to equity, justice, and liberation through culturally responsive evaluation practice. Most conferences focus on how you do the work. CREA was about how you relate to the work and to each other. Imagine a family reunion with relatives you actually want to see (plus yoga led by monique liston, aka Thing 2, iykyk).

Nina came ready to lead a roundtable called Impact Investing 101. It was an IMM primer for culturally responsive evaluation (CRE) practitioners, designed for evaluators who were curious about the space but new to it.

Nobody showed up.

Some of that was logistics. There were a lot of concurrent sessions, and the roundtable layout didn’t do anyone favors. We’re not above blaming the floor plan. But it would be pretty un-evaluator-like to explain away a data point just because we don’t like it. So we’re sitting with it, and here’s where we’ve landed:

IMM needs culturally responsive evaluators. We’re just not sure the two fields are ready for each other yet.

First, why IMM needs CRE. Private foundations are required to pay out at least 5% of their endowment each year. The other 95% is invested, often in companies whose practices contradict the foundation’s own mission. Impact investing puts that capital to work for communities. Impact Measurement & Management (IMM) is how investors decide whether it’s actually working.

IMM is an evaluation practice. It just grew up in finance… far from CRE (which grew up in education). You can see it in who gets to define success. According to the GIIN’s 2020 survey, roughly 91% of impact investors select their own metrics. Only about 31% involve investees, and fewer still involve the communities the capital is meant to benefit. Investors also tend to treat data quality as a technical problem. CRE practitioners know it’s a relational one: how you ask and who asks shapes what you learn.

The fields don’t even agree on what “equity” means. In finance, equity is an ownership stake. In CRE, equity is justice and the redistribution of power. Capital is not neutral, and CRE practitioners are trained to make that tension visible.

So why the empty chairs? CREA’s own conference theme put it well: opportunity is not neutral. Many CRE practitioners have built their careers in the grants world, and they have good reasons to be wary of anything that sounds like Wall Street. That isn’t a gap in interest or skill. It’s a bridge that hasn’t been built yet. That responsibility falls on folks like us, who stand on both sides of it.

So instead of waiting for CRE practitioners to come to the IMM table, we’re bringing the table to them. The handout Nina made for the session is ready to share. Hit reply and we’ll send it your way. 💜

Now we want to hear from you. CRE folks: what would make you pull up a chair? IMM folks: who’s in the room when you decide what counts as impact?

IN OUR HEARTS

Our Field’s Spookiest Tricks & Treats 👻

It’s spooky season, so we asked the team to name the thing in our field that makes them want to hide under the covers (looking at you, 47-arrow logic model) — and the treat that makes the work worth it. Funny thing: a lot of what scares us isn’t scary so much as sneaky. The stuff dressed up to look like good practice that… isn’t. 👻

Animated cards sharing each I2I team member’s spookiest trick and favorite treat in the evaluation field

What’s hiding under your covers this season — and what’s the treat that keeps you going? Hit reply and spill. 🍬

UP OUR SLEEVES

New Client Spotlight

Since July, we’ve had the honor to work with the California Wellness Foundation.

Earlier this year, Cal Wellness just set a bold new direction with Building the Power to Be Well, a strategic framework that names the forces actually deciding who gets to be healthy in California: race, money, and power (their words — and they don’t flinch from them 💪). It’s a foundation committing to move its mission with not just its grantmaking, but its endowment investments and its voice and influence — and to share power with its grant partners in directing where the resources go.

We’re helping Cal Wellness build an impact framework that brings all its levers — grantmaking, endowment, voice and influence — into one, integrated view. The point isn’t to tally outputs. It’s to understand the contributions they’re making to partners, communities, and the broader field, and to hold themselves accountable for how they show up: checking that their actions actually match their intent, and that their values are showing up in the decisions they make.

This is the kind of work we live for — not how much a foundation gives, but whether it’s living what it says. Stay tuned as more unfolds!

Onward and upward, y’all!

You know, heart-2-hearts are supposed to be a 2-way street…

So comment below, what’s on your mind, in your heart, and up your sleeve? Hopefully a lil’ bit of good trouble. 😉

Subscribe to the newsletter here!

Until next time,
Intention 2 Impact

Our Latest Musings